Skip to content

eclectic librarian

random musings from a serialist

  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • CV
  • Contact Me
eclectic librarian

Tag: Data exchange

NASIG 2010: Making E-Serials Holdings Data Transferable–Applying the KBART Recommended Practice

Presenters: Jason Price, Claremont Colleges Library and SCELC Consortium

KBART stands for Knowledge Bases and Related Tools (a NISO group). Standards and best practices are challenging to move forward, so why should we “back this horse” versus something else?

This group is a collection of publishers, aggregators, knowledge base vendors, and librarians who want to create a universally acceptable holdings data format. Phase one of the report came out in January of this year, and the endorsement phase begins this month.

KBART expresses title level coverage by date and volume/issue. It’s a single solution for sharing holdings data across the scholarly communications supply chain. Essentially, it’s a simple metadata exchange format.

It wasn’t a simple process to get to this schema. They thought about all of the data in knowledge bases, how data is transferred to and from other sources, and the role of licensing in this process. When a publisher produces content, it flows to hosts/databases then gateways then knowledge bases and then catalogs/lists/guides.

When a user has a citation, they initiate a process that queries the knowledge base, which returns a list of access points. However, this breaks down when the holdings information is incorrect or even worse, when it’s missing. We get stuck with a lot of inaccuracies and manual work. At some point, it gets to be too much to keep up with.

Everyone is working with the same kind of data, albeit slightly customized at a local level. If we can begin to move toward a standard way of distributing the data, we can then look at automating this process.

KBART is the end to our role as translators – no more badgering publishers for complete lists, no more teasing out title changes (including former titles and ISSNs), no more waiting for the knowledge base data team to translate the data, and no more out of date access lists.

What can librarians do? Learn more about KBART. Insist on “knowing” what you’re buying (require annual delivery of a useable holdings list before you pay). Enable publisher sales staff to make the case to their companies – show them that use goes up when it’s accurately represented in link resolvers. Follow up with continued requests as necessary.

The American Institute of Physics implemented the KBART standard on their own, and they’ve now officially joined the group. On the other hand “A Big Publisher” recognizes the problem, but they need to establish the priority of the change, which includes getting their hosting service to make appropriate changes. So, they need to hear from all of us about this.

Publishers who are interested should review the requirements and format the content availability data to meet those requirements. Check your work and make it available to customers. And, of course, register as a KBART member.

Vision for KBART: Currently in phase one of standardizing. Phase two is more content type coverage. Phase three is a dream of incorporating metadata distribution for consortia and institutional level holdings based on what is accessible from a particular IP.

Author AnnaPosted on June 6, 2010Categories libraryTags American Institute of Physics, Claremont Colleges Library, data, Data exchange, Data management, Database, holdings, information, Jason Price, KBART, Knowledge representation, librarian, library science, metadata, nasig2010, OpenURL knowledge base, Related Tools, scholarly communications supply chain, serials, Technical communicationLeave a comment on NASIG 2010: Making E-Serials Holdings Data Transferable–Applying the KBART Recommended Practice
  • October 2026 statsNovember 10, 2026
  • September 2026 statsOctober 2, 2026
  • August 2026 StatsSeptember 1, 2026
  • keeping track of work thingsApril 15, 2025
  • running is kind of…fun?February 12, 2025
  1. barrywynn on running is kind of…fun?February 12, 2025

    Yay for getting it done!

  2. barrywynn on board games played in Jan 2025February 6, 2025

    Thanks for the reviews. Been wanting to try more board games.

  3. Kathryn Greenhill on NASIG Annual 2023June 2, 2023

    Thanks for this Anna. With the decline of the birdsite (and my decision not to play there) I am feeling…

Recent Photo
Recently Played Board Games
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • CV
  • Contact Me
eclectic librarian Proudly powered by WordPress